Monday, 30 September 2013

Man Utd

Manchester United slumped to a third league defeat of the season as West Brom recorded a first win at Old Trafford for 35 years this weekend. This came a week after being humiliated by their Manchester neighbours. The champions have won once in their first six league matches and are yet to record a home win in the league. It's fair to say David Moyes has made a poor start to his tenure as Sir Alex Ferguson's successor. Moyes recently told several national newspapers he feels his premier league winning squad is short of quality. This will frustrate many United fans as substantial transfer funds were seemingly available in the summer, only for Moyes to miss out on the signings of his leading transfer targets. I think this resulted in the club’s brand being damaged as players’ turning down Manchester United is almost unheard of. Other targets then had to be pursued and Marouane Fellaini became a United player on the final day of the transfer window, by which time, the club’s only major signing of the summer’s buyout clause in his contract at Everton had ran out which caused United having to pay £4,000,000 more for their man. While Moyes didn’t win a trophy or gain much champions league experience in his eleven years at Everton, I, like most people am convinced by his credentials after guiding Preston to the division two title in his first managerial job before building stability and consistency at the Merseyside club he labelled ‘The People’s Club.’ Despite this, I can’t help but question the decisions he is making. Admittedly, I’m a novice in comparison to Moyes and his wealth of top level football experience, but like many football fans, I have an opinion on the matter. Moyes’ side were 4-0 down in the Manchester derby when he eventually saw it fit to make a substitution when he brought on Tom Cleverly in replacement for the more offensive Ashley Young, leaving the attacking forces of shinji kagawa, Javier Hernandez, and Nani on the bench. At this stage, Moyes obviously resorted to damaged limitations, but we’ll never know whether United could have fought back had more attacking players being introduced earlier. It’s clear David Moyes has made mistakes since taking on the incredibly difficult job of replacing the most successful British manager of all time. Perhaps mistakes are to be expected and maybe he deserves to be cut a bit of slack as success takes time. But it is inevitable that he will be compared to Sir Alex and I find it hard to believe that had he still been at the helm, United would have had such a succession of below par performances and results.